Picture of a bookcase at a divorce and criminal defense law firm in Pinehurst, North Carolina

Personal Injury Settlement Taxes & Payouts

Personal injury settlements offer some relief to anyone who's been the victim of a slip and fall, a car accident, or any other incident where the actions of someone else have left them paying the emotional, physical, and financial costs. Whether it’s for pain and suffering, medical bills, or lost wages, a personal injury lawsuit settlement or payout  is a way to regain some control, find justice, and maybe even a bit of peace of mind.

Picture of a doctor bandaging a broken hand

While securing compensation is crucial, it can be complicated. Many are left wondering about the tax implications of their personal injury settlement.  Here, our pros at Van Camp, Meacham & Newman address some common questions about personal injury settlements and taxes in North Carolina. 

Federal Tax Code for Personal Injury Settlement Taxes

The Internal Revenue Code, also known as the IRC, is the comprehensive set of tax laws enacted by the United States Congress. When it comes to taxes and payouts of a personal injury settlement, understanding the tax implications under the federal tax code can help get the most out of a case.   

Tax Treatment of Compensation for Injuries

Under the federal tax code, compensation received for personal physical injuries or physical sickness is generally not considered taxable income. This applies to amounts received through settlements, judgments, or awards stemming from personal injury lawsuits. Because these settlements are designed to provide relief to individuals who have suffered harm, this exemption is in place to make sure that their compensation is not reduced by tax liabilities.

Exceptions and Limitations

While compensation for physical injuries or sickness is typically non-taxable, there are exceptions and limitations outlined in the federal tax code. Those include:

  • Punitive Damages: Punitive damages are intended to punish the defendant for egregious conduct rather than compensate the plaintiff for their injuries. Still, punitive damages paid by the defendant are awarded to the plaintiff, so they might be included in a personal injury settlement. According to the federal tax code, the portion of a settlement that is designated as punitive damages is taxable.
  • Emotional Distress: Compensation for emotional distress or mental anguish stemming from physical injuries or sickness is generally tax-free. However, if the emotional distress is not directly related to a physical injury or sickness, the tax treatment may vary.
  • Tax Treatment of Non-Physical Injuries: Compensation for non-physical injuries, such as defamation, discrimination, or invasion of privacy, is typically taxable under the Federal Tax Code. These types of damages are considered income and are subject to taxation unless specifically exempted by law.
  • Structured Settlements and Annuities: In some cases, personal injury settlements may involve structured payments or annuities rather than a lump-sum payment. Under the Federal Tax Code, the tax treatment of structured settlements depends on various factors, including whether the payments represent compensation for physical injuries or sickness.
  • Reporting Requirements: Taxpayers receiving compensation for injuries or sickness should ensure compliance with reporting requirements outlined in the federal tax code. This includes accurately reporting taxable income, exemptions, and deductions related to personal injury settlements on their tax returns.

Commonly Asked Questions About the Tax Implications of Personal Injury Settlements

Payouts from personal injury settlements are meant to take some of the stress off of victims in the aftermath of an accident, not add to it. The tax implications of a settlement shouldn’t change that. Let’s dive into some of the most common questions about taxes on a personal injury settlement to clear up confusion and simplify every scenario. 

Are Personal Injury Settlements Taxable?

One of the most frequently asked questions is whether a personal injury settlement is subject to taxation. In most cases, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) does not consider personal injury settlements as taxable income. However, there are exceptions to this general rule.

What are Exceptions to Non-Taxable Settlements? 

While the majority of personal injury settlements are not taxable, certain circumstances may lead to a portion of the settlement being subject to taxation. Some common exceptions include punitive damages, interest on the settlement, and some emotional damages. 

How are Medical Expenses Taxed in a Personal Injury Settlement? 

Generally, amounts received for medical expenses related to personal injuries are not taxable. However, it is essential to keep detailed records of these expenses to substantiate the tax-free nature of the settlement.

What Is the Difference Between How Structured Settlements and Lump-Sum Payments are Taxed in a Personal Injury Settlement? 

Personal injury settlements can be structured in various ways, including receiving a lump sum or periodic payments. While lump-sum payments are typically tax-free, structured settlements may involve interest income, which could be subject to taxation.

When Should I Consult a Tax Professional About Taxes In a Personal Injury Settlement?

The nuances and potential exceptions of taxation on a personal injury settlement can be made clearer with the help of a qualified tax professional or attorney. An experienced tax advisor can provide personalized guidance based on the specific details of the settlement, ensuring compliance with tax laws and optimizing the financial outcome for the injured party.

Do I Have to Report Personal Injury Settlement to the IRS?

In most cases, you are not required to report a personal injury settlement to the IRS as income. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) generally considers compensation for personal physical injuries or sickness as non-taxable. This includes amounts received through settlements, judgments, or awards related to personal injury claims. 

However, it is crucial to keep in mind certain exceptions, such as punitive damages and interest on the settlement, which may be subject to taxation. To ensure compliance with tax laws and navigate potential complexities, consulting with a qualified tax professional is usually recommended. 

Can the IRS Take My Personal Injury Settlement if I Owe Back Taxes?

Yes, the IRS has the authority to offset your personal injury settlement to satisfy any outstanding federal tax debts. If you owe back taxes, the IRS may use the Federal Payment Levy Program (FPLP) to automatically levy certain federal payments, including settlements, to cover the tax debt. It's crucial to be aware of your tax obligations and address any outstanding debts promptly. 

Seeking advice from a tax professional can help you navigate the complexities of tax law, explore potential solutions, and ensure that you take the necessary steps to minimize the impact of any tax obligations on your personal injury settlement.

Can a Lawsuit Settlement Affect your Social Security Disability Payments?

Yes, a lawsuit settlement can potentially impact your Social Security Disability (SSD) payments, though it depends on the kinds of benefits you are applying for. While a personal injury settlement will likely not affect Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI), it may affect Supplemental Security Income (SSI).

The impact on your payments also depends on the nature of the settlement. If the settlement is for compensation related to pain and suffering, emotional distress, or punitive damages, it generally does not affect payments. However, if the settlement includes compensation for lost wages or medical expenses, it may be considered income and could potentially affect your eligibility. 

It's crucial to report any changes in your financial situation, including lawsuit settlements, to the SSA promptly. Failure to report such changes could result in overpayments or other complications. Consulting with a legal professional or a Social Security Disability attorney can provide guidance on how a specific settlement may impact your benefits and help ensure compliance with reporting requirements to safeguard your payments.

What Is the Formula for Personal Injury Settlements?

The calculation of a personal injury settlement doesn't follow a strict formula, as it involves a nuanced consideration of various factors. Typically, the process includes assessing economic damages such as medical expenses and lost wages, alongside non-economic damages like pain and suffering. Liability, insurance limits, and legal fees are also key elements. The negotiation skills of involved attorneys play a crucial role in determining the final settlement amount. Each case is unique, and the outcome depends on the specifics of the incident, the jurisdiction's laws, and the legal representation.

What Is the Average Personal Injury Settlement Figure?

Determining the average personal injury settlement figure is difficult, as settlement amounts vary widely based on the specifics of each case. Settlements are influenced by factors such as the severity of injuries, medical expenses, lost wages, emotional distress, and liability considerations. Cases involving catastrophic injuries or long-term disabilities tend to result in higher settlements. 

While some sources estimate average settlement figures at between $3,000 and $8,000, those figures should be approached with caution, as they might not accurately reflect the diversity of personal injury cases. 

How Do I Know If I Owe Taxes on My Personal Injury Settlement?

Determining whether you owe taxes on your personal injury settlement involves considering various factors related to the nature of the settlement and applicable tax laws, and consulting with both your personal injury attorney and a tax professional. 

How Do I File Taxes for My Personal Injury Settlement?

To ascertain your tax liability, start by reviewing the details of your settlement. If you received a 1099 form, typically a 1099-MISC, from the payer, it will indicate the amount of income you need to report to the IRS. If you didn't receive a 1099, it's still your responsibility to report the settlement on your tax return accurately.

When filing your taxes, use the appropriate tax form based on your circumstances, such as Form 1040 or Form 1040-SR. If your settlement is non-taxable, clearly indicate this on your return. If any part is taxable, report it in the "Other Income" section, specifying the nature of the compensation. Proper documentation is crucial, so retain records of medical bills, legal fees, and other relevant details that support the tax-free status of your settlement.

What Happens If I Don't Get a 1099 for a Settlement?

If you don't receive a 1099 for a settlement, it's important to take proactive steps to ensure accurate tax reporting. While not all settlements require a 1099 form, it is the responsibility of the payer to issue this form if the settlement includes taxable income. 

In the absence of a 1099, it does not exempt you from reporting the settlement on your tax return. Ensure you maintain thorough records of the settlement details, including any compensatory or punitive damages, to accurately report the income. If you're uncertain about the tax implications or need assistance, consulting with a tax professional is advisable. They can provide guidance on proper reporting procedures, help you understand potential tax liabilities, and ensure compliance with tax regulations. 

Making Your Personal Injury Settlement Tax-Free

While there is no guaranteed way to be sure that none of your personal injury settlement will be tax free, there are a few considerations you can take and discuss with your personal injury attorney to maximize the financial benefits of your recovery.

Documenting the Nature of Damages

One of the key factors in a personal injury settlement is clearly documenting the nature of the damages. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) generally considers compensation for physical injuries or sickness as non-taxable. That means it is essential to establish a direct link between the settlement amount and the specific physical harm suffered. Keeping detailed records of medical bills, treatment plans, and expert opinions can strengthen your case for a tax-free settlement.

Allocating Damages Appropriately

Careful allocation of damages is important to any personal injury settlement, especially one that you hope to be tax-free. Clearly specifying the portions of the settlement designated for medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering can help ensure that each component is treated appropriately under the tax code. 

It’s also a good idea to consider how the settlement will be paid; lump-sum payments are often taxed differently than structured payments.

Avoiding Punitive Damages

Punitive damages, designed to punish the defendant for intentional or reckless conduct, are generally considered taxable income by the IRS. To maintain the tax-free status of your settlement, work with your legal team to ensure that the compensation sought is focused on compensatory damages for actual harm rather than punitive damages.

Seeking Professional Tax Advice

Navigating the complexities of tax law can be challenging, and seeking professional tax advice is highly recommended. Consult with a qualified tax professional who has experience in personal injury settlements to ensure that your case is structured in a way that complies with tax regulations. An expert can provide personalized guidance based on your specific circumstances and help you explore potential deductions related to the settlement.

Consideration of Emotional Distress

Compensation for emotional distress is generally non-taxable if it is directly linked to a physical injury or sickness. However, if emotional distress is the primary basis for the settlement and is not tied to a physical injury, tax implications may vary. Clarifying the connection between emotional distress and physical harm in your case is essential for maintaining a tax-free status.

Structured Settlements and Annuities

Explore the option of structured settlements or annuities, which can provide a steady stream of tax-free income over time. Structuring the settlement in this way may help minimize the tax impact, especially when dealing with large settlement amounts.

Why Consult a Personal Injury Attorney 

An attorney helps you navigate the tax implications of your personal injury settlement and comply with relevant tax laws. 

Understanding Taxability

Attorneys specializing in personal injury law have a deep understanding of the tax implications associated with settlements. They can assess the components of your settlement, such as compensatory damages, punitive damages, or interest, and determine the taxability of each portion.

Proper Documentation

Attorneys can help you gather and organize the necessary documentation to support your tax filing. This includes records of medical expenses, legal fees, and other relevant details that can impact the taxable status of your settlement.

Communication with Payers

In some cases, your attorney may communicate directly with the payer of the settlement to ensure that the appropriate tax forms, such as a 1099-MISC, are issued accurately and promptly. This can help streamline the tax reporting process for you.

Tax Planning

Attorneys can provide strategic tax planning advice to help you optimize your financial situation. This may involve structuring the settlement in a way that minimizes tax liabilities or exploring options such as structured settlements to provide a steady income over time.

Coordination with Tax Professionals

Attorneys often work in collaboration with tax professionals, ensuring that your legal and tax strategies align seamlessly. This collaboration can provide a comprehensive approach to addressing both legal and tax considerations.

Handling Complex Cases

 If your personal injury case involves complex issues, such as multiple defendants, insurance claims, or disputes over the nature of damages, an attorney can navigate these complexities to accurately determine the tax implications of your settlement.

Appealing IRS Decisions

In the event of any disputes with the IRS regarding the tax treatment of your settlement, an attorney can represent you and help navigate the appeals process, ensuring that your rights and interests are protected.

Final Word: Personal Injury Settlement Taxes & Payouts

Navigating the world of personal injury settlement taxes and payouts can be complicated and confusing—but it becomes much simpler with the help of a both personal injury attorney and a tax professional. 

If you need help with your personal injury settlement or case, contact Van Camp, Meacham, & Newman today. You can schedule a consultation or speak with one of our personal injury attorneys for all of your personal injury settlement taxation questions. 

Van Camp Law Firm in Pinehurst, North Carolina

Contact Our Pinehurst Law Firm Today

Please call  910-295-2525 or fill out our form below.
Your Name(Required)
*Free consultations excludes Domestic/Family law.
By submitting this form, you are consenting to our privacy policy.
By contacting us, no attorney-client relationship is created.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.